Forum | Register | Ranks | BBS Skins | Forum Support | Forum Archive

 

 

series

 

 Other Content
 Smallville
 Lost
 Heroes
 Star Trek: VOY
 Star Trek
 Star Trek: TNG
 Star Trek: DS9
 Mission Logs

 Site Info
 
Staff
 News Archives

 Site FAQ
 Contact
 Terms of Use
 Legal Notice

 Submit News

 Forums
 Main
 Register
 Ranks
 BBS Skins
 Forum Support

Crossroads, part 2
Original Airdate: March 25, 2007
Reviewed by DMD

Summary | Review | Screen Caps | Cast | Guest Cast | Creative Staff

Summary

We're treated to a sampling of the crews' morning. Adama wakes up and shaves, cutting himself in the process. Roslin phones Adama and has him order her out of bead because she doesn't want to face the day. Tyrol wakes up humming the strange music that Anders and Tigh seemed to hear in part 1, then he goes stumbling through the ship's corridors, searching for the source of the music. Eventually Tyrol finds a good spot to listen to the music through the ship. It seems to soothe him. Speaking of Anders, he and Tory spent some quality time together in the barracks. It seems that Tory can hear the music, too. Round two gets interrupted by Seelix.

Lee comes up with the idea of asking for a mistrial, based on Adama's comments to him that Baltar doesn't even deserve a trial. How fair can the trial be if one of the judges doesn't even find the defendant deserving of a hearing? Lee quotes from his grandfather's book that a mistrial helps the defense because the prosecution has already tipped their hand. Baltar won't hear of it. He can't take the strain of another trial, thinks they're doing well, and wants a verdict.

Anders shows up as one of the nuggets training to be a pilot. He's distracted by the sound of the music, then notices that Tyrol is humming the same tune. Tyrol sounds relieved to find someone else that can hear the music. He mentions something about "a way out." They both think of it like something from their childhood that they can't quite remember fully.

Roslin receives her first cancer treatment. She dozes off and has a similar dream to the one she had in part 1. She's in the same opera house that Baltar saw himself in on Kobol. She chases an older Hera down the steps, as does one of the Sharons (Boomer or Athena?). Hera runs into Six's arms. Roslin sees Baltar in the dream and wakes up screaming. At the same moment, Athena screams. She's also in the infirmary with Hera. Roslin goes to Athena and says they need to talk.

Roslin and Athena visit Six in her cell. They dismiss the guards and Roslin asks if Six was with them in the lobby of the opera house. She was. Roslin tells her that Athena was there, too, and Six says that shouldn't be possible. Was Six trying to reach Hera? She doesn't know, she just knew that she had to protect Hera with her life.

Tigh is in Adama's office telling him about the music in the walls of the ship. Adama can't hear it, but he promises to look into it. Tigh doesn't think Adama is taking him seriously, and says that the music is Cylon sabotage. Adama doesn't see how music would be an effective method of sabotage, but again promises to look into. Right now, he has to get to court. After Adama leaves, Tigh says to himself, "there must be some kinda way outta here."

In court, Gaeta is on the stand. The prosecutor shows him the death list that Baltar signed. He lies and said that he saw Baltar sign it. The prosecutor asks if Baltar protested or argued in any way against signing. We see a flashback of Baltar refusing to sign, and a Cylon holding a gun to Baltar's head and demanding he sign. Gaeta testifies that Baltar simply signed without protest. Lampkin decides not to cross examine Gaeta, which infuriates Baltar. Lampkin explains that if Gaeta has decided to perjure himself, there's nothing he can do about it. They'll have to change tactics.

When court resumes, Lampkin moves for a mistrial against Baltar's wishes. He calls Lee to the stand, intending to get him to tell the court what Adama had said about Baltar not being worthy of a trial. Instead, he tells the court that Baltar should be acquitted because the charges haven't been proven. He reminds the court that Baltar was in an impossible position, and that not appearing to cooperate with the Cylons would probably have resulted in them nuking the planet right then and there. He reminds them of Roslin's blanket pardon, and asks why Baltar is the one person that pardon doesn't appear to cover. He goes on, at length, about all the things that various people have done since the attack on the colonies that have been forgiven, and says that the they're heaping their collective guilt on Baltar, hoping they can toss it all out the air lock along with him. The prosecutor takes exception to having Lee testify, but has no questions. The defense rests.

The verdict comes in. By a thee to two vote, Baltar is found not guilty. The courtroom erupts, with some people applauding the verdict and others wanting to kill Baltar themselves. Baltar is soon escorted out of the courtroom by security. As he gathers his things from his cell, he thanks his defense team, but says he would like to have seen Adama squirm a bit more. Lee gets in his face and advises the doctor not to push it. Baltar tries to get Lampkin to help him with legal issues surrounding his publishing rights and a book tour of the fleet. Lampkin isn't interested. Finally, Baltar asks what's to become of him. Where will he live? What will he do? Lampkin just tells him he's sure to land on his feet.

On the bridge, Roslin's stomach is turning at the idea of Baltar being innocent. Adama reminds her that there's a big difference between being found not guilty and being innocent. As much as it galls him to say it, he was one of the three who voted for acquittal. He tells Roslin that the defense made its case, and the prosecution didn't. Roslin tells him that they both know that Baltar is a traitor, regardless of the outcome of the trial. He tells her that no one's asking anyone to forgive or forget, but they have to look to the future. He then orders Gaeta to commence preparations for the jump to the Ionan nebula.

As Baltar carries his belongings through the Galactica's corridors, getting numerous dirty looks along the way, the fleet jumps to the nebula. Soon after arriving, Roslin begins to feel faint. Then the entire fleet starts to experience power fluctuations, eventually resulting in power loss. As the crew scrambles to find a way to restore power, we see Tigh hugging one of the walls, listening to the music.

The ship is operating on battery power only. As Gaius wanders in the near-dark, three women corner him. Rather than attack him, they tell him they're taking him to his new life. Six rests uneasily in her cell, then finds herself back in the opera house with Baltar and Athena. They're on the stage of the opera house. They look up into the upper balcony and see the final five Cylons in white robes, their faces hidden. Then, she's back in her cell.

Tyrol seems in a daze as people race around him. He hears the strange music again and says, "there must be some kinda way outta here." Cut to Tigh, who says, "said the joker to the thief." Cut to Anders in the barracks. He's stumbles out saying there's too much confusion there. Cut to Tory. She's overcome by a wave of nausea, then looks in a mirror and says, "I can't get no relief."

Tyrol, Anders, Tory and Tigh all independently end up in the same room. None of them wants to believe they can be Cylons. Tory, Anders and Tyrol all start humming the music together. Tigh cuts them off. He starts ranting about his forty years in the service, his treatment on New Caprica, and Helen. Anders points out his time in the resistance. Tyrol tells them it's all true. They're Cylons, and they have been since the beginning.

Power is restored simultaneously throughout the fleet. A massive Cylon fleet is detected. Adama orders an emergency jump, but with the power outage, it will take at least twenty minutes to power up the FTL drives.

The possible Cylon-four hear the announcement about the Cylon fleet. Tigh tells them that whatever else he may be, he's an officer in this fleet, and if the fleet is under attack, he's going to be at his post. He leaves the room, followed by the others. They all return to their jobs. Lee, too, decides it's time to ditch the suit for his uniform. The vipers launch to meet the incoming Cylon fleet.

Lee detects an enemy ship apart from the main fleet. He breaks formation to check it out, but it soon disappears from his screen. It's still out there, though, as the bogey, another viper, flashes by his ship. It's Starbuck. She tells Lee that everything is going to be alright. She says she's been to Earth. She knows where it is, and she's going to take them there.

Return to top

Review

And with that, Season 3 is wrapped. I thought it was a fairly good end to an uneven season. Starbuck is back, in one fashion or another. We still don't know the specifics on that. The colonial fleet is faced with a massive Cylon fleet once again. The fact that Starbuck's return coincides with the presence of the Cylons and the 'awakening' of four of the five final Cylons, though, has me wondering if an all-out battle is really coming.

Perhaps there's something different going on here. They Cylons we've been dealing with until now were following the fleet. Why bother if you already know where they're going? There's something special about this particular location in space, something that resonated with Tory, Tyrol, Tigh and Anders the closer they came to it. That a Cylon fleet and Starbuck would all be waiting for them and the colonial fleet can't be a coincidence. I won't be surprised if Leoben's (paraphrased) words to Starbuck, "all of this has happened before," come into play when the cliffhanger is resolved. After all, if Tigh has always been a Cylon, and if Tigh fought in the first Cylon war, then Cylons have had the ability to appear human long, long before we'd previously thought.

Back to the episode at hand. Baltar's acquittal was almost a given. As central to the premise as that character is, he couldn't just get jettisoned out the airlock. Lee's speech was probably the best way to achieve that end. Everything he said on the stand holds true. Yes, Baltar is a traitor, but are his sins really any worse than everyone else's? Are they worse than Tigh's, or Lee's, or Helo's, or Adama's, or Roslin's, or, or, or ? In some ways, yes, since Baltar put the entire remaining human race in danger, but Roslin issued a blanket pardon for anything done on New Caprica, and no one brought up, nor could they likely prove, that Baltar was responsible for the Cylon's ease in attacking the Colonies. Or his helping the Cylons locate Earth. Now I'm wondering why the prosecution wouldn't at least bring these things up?

Actually, Baltar's acquittal brings up an interesting question, shouldn't he still be the President? I don't recall him resigning or being impeached, though it might be more difficult for Baltar to escape an impeachment trial.

So in some ways, events in the finale were predictable. Baltar had to be acquitted. Lee had to end up back in the pilot's seat. Starbuck had to make an appearance. Some sort of surprise had to be waiting for the fleet when they reached the nebula. Still, the way these things worked themselves into the episode was satisfying, perhaps even unexpected.

So what to expect from next season? We don't know exactly where the colonies were in relation to our own position in the galaxy, but the end of the episode sure made it look like we're getting to be in the same neighborhood, so I'd guess the hunt for Earth will become more urgent. The Cylon plan that the show's intro has always mentioned may finally come into sharper focus. I'm not going to be surprised to find that the plans of the Cylons that attacked the colonies are going to simply be part of a larger plan that those Cylons weren't even aware of. There's a certain 'hand of fate' aspect to all of this that makes me think that we have only seen glimpses of the real plan. Unfortunately, we're looking at nine months before the next season begins, so there's plenty of time for speculation.

Return to top

Grade: 9/10

Screen Caps

   

Return to top

Cast:

Edward James Olmos as Commander William "Husker" Adama
Mary McDonnell
as President Laura Roslin
Jamie Bamber as Captain Lee 'Apollo' Adama
James Callis
as Doctor/Vice President Gaius Baltar
Tricia Helfer
as Six
Grace Park
as Lt. Sharon 'Boomer' Valerii / Eight

Return to top

Guest Cast:

Michael Hogan as Col. Saul Tigh
Aaron Douglas as Chief Petty Officer Galen Tyrol
Nicki Clyne as Crewman Specialist Cally
Tahmoh Penikett as Lt. Karl 'Helo' Agathon
Alessandro Juliani as Lt. Gaeta
Kandyse McClure
as Dualla
Michael Trucco
as Anders
Mark Sheppard
as Romo Lampkin
Donnelly Rhodes as Doc Cottle
Rekha Sharma
as Tory Foster
Chelah Horsdal
as Didi Cassidy
Katee Sackhoff
as Lt. Kara 'Starbuck' Thrace
Leah Cairns
as Racetrack
Jennifer Halley
as Seelix
Brad Dryborough
as Hoshi
Alison Matthews
as Fallbrook
William Samples
as Tribunal Judge
Susan Hogan
as Captain Franks
Keegan Connor Tracy as Young Woman
Lily Duong-Walton
as Hera Agathon

Return to top

 

Creative Staff:

Written By: Mark Verheiden
Director: Michael Rymer

Return to top

 

The news script update utility used by Lowerdecks staff Copyright 2003 Andrew Bailey. NOT authorized for use outside the Lowerdecks.com or Trek-UK.com domains without prior consent. Contact Andrew at tcn@lowerdecks.com for more information.

Site Requirements: Optimal viewing with use of Internet Explorer 5.5+ with 1024x768 screen resolution.

Star Trek ® is copyright of Paramount Pictures. Copyright © 1966, Present. The Star Trek web pages on this site are for educational and entertainment purposes only. All other copyrights property of their respective holders.

®2002-Present Lowerdecks.com