Forum | Register | Ranks | BBS Skins | Forum Support | Forum Archive

 

 

series

 

 Other Content
 Smallville
 Lost
 Heroes
 Star Trek: VOY
 Star Trek
 Star Trek: TNG
 Star Trek: DS9
 Mission Logs

 Site Info
 
Staff
 News Archives

 Site FAQ
 Contact
 Terms of Use
 Legal Notice

 Submit News

 Forums
 Main
 Register
 Ranks
 BBS Skins
 Forum Support

A Measure of Salvation
Original Airdate: November 10, 2006
Reviewed By Cartagia

Summary | Review | Screen Caps | Cast | Guest Cast | Creative Staff

Summary

Following the events of “Torn” a small contingent of Vipers is sent to investigate the dying base star. Athena confirms that it was disabled by something she has never seen before. Apollo says he doesn’t think it will offer them any resistance. A landing team begins to investigate the desolate ship. The team finds the dead Cylons and has no idea what is happening. Athena hooks into the computer system to try and discover what has happened. As she does the team finds 5 living Cylons. A dying Eight calls Athena a traitor but warns her to stay away because of the disease.

On Galactica Doc Cottle prepares quarantine procedures for the returning landing party. Cottle wants to examine the captured Cylons so he can possibly find a cure.

As the team returns the base ship explodes.

On the other base ship, Caprica Six and Three confront Baltar; asking how long he will betray them. They know about the beacon, and think that he led the ship there to infect the Cylons. He apologizes for excluding the beacon in his report. Two centurions enter the room and Three says they expect to get all the information he knows… and Baltar finds himself on a beach with Six, trying to hide from his torture. The only thing he tells them is that he is in love with Caprica Six.

In the quarantine Cottle comes to an antsy crew to tell them that humans are immune and they are all free to go, but doesn’t let Athena leave. Helo is upset that Cottle hasn’t yet done her blood work.

After Cottle studies the captured Cylons he quickly finds a cure. The Cylons would require regular injections of his antibodies, but he can cure them. However Apollo decides to ask the “ugly question”… should they keep them alive? Helo and Adama both think that they should be kept for intelligence gathering.

During the interrogation the Simon model explains how the disease could easily spread throughout the Cylons if one of them was downloaded in a resurrection ship. He also tells the crew that Baltar pointed them in the direction of the lion nebula. Simon tells the crew that the Cylons want a new beginning, much like the humans. As Simon is lead away Apollo realizes that they can use the disease as a weapon. He then explains his plan to Roslin.

Helo objects, calling it genocide. Say that it makes them no different than the Cylons. Roslin disagrees, saying that it wasn’t they who set out to destroy a race of people. Helo responds by saying that at least they tried to live together on New Caprica. He also says that if Athena can be the way she is, can’t other Cylons?

In his projected reality Baltar’s Six is trying to get him to concentrate on something other than the pain. She helps him get away from the pain. In the real world he tells Three that he had nothing to do with the virus. While talking with Three Baltar tells her that he can help her reconcile faith and fact. While talking to his imaginary Six he says I love you to Three.

When Helo returns to his quarters he finds Athena, who is immune to the virus. Carrying the hybrid child to term unleashed some anti-bodies that nullified the disease. Helo then tells his wife about the plan to infect the Cylons.

As Adama and Roslin have a drink he says that he isn’t allowed to use biological weapons without a Presidential order… and Roslin orders it.

Athena tells Helo that she made a decision to wear a uniform, and she will stick with that decision even if she is the last Cylon in the universe.

Galactica jumps and prepares for their plan to infect a resurrection ship. The prisoners will be executed when the Cylons show up. In the brig, the Cylons are already dead, so the plan has become moot. The ship jumps before a major battle occurs.

Helo prepares to be taken away, taking solace in that he did what he thought was right. But he won’t be taken away, Adama won’t investigate the charges. He also tells here that the beacon was accidentally contaminated 3,000 years ago, when the 13th colony left.

Return to top

Review

Two episodes in a row with “So say we all.” Again, a nice throwaway to the original series.

The moral dilemma presented in the argument is presented well on both sides I think, but it really surprises me that Roslin was so ready to order the execution of the Cylon race. It almost seemed like a change made solely for the fact that there’s no way it could be done without Presidential approval.

Athena’s immunity just seemed like another convenient plot point. While not far fetched, you would think that it would have made no difference for Cottle to develop a full-blown cure. It just seemed like a forced way to have Athena and Helo think about their lost child.

I also don’t know why this episode was listed and touted as a two-parter. The only carry over was the disease, and with the show being as serialized as it is already, it was strange. Especially with the total focus shifts between the two haves (almost no Starbuck or Tigh here).

Though even with these complaints it is a very well acted and written episode. It was engaging and had a good point to make. How far will the humans go? Sometimes it seems like the Cylon’s are right about them. They are unstable.

It also reminded me of an episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation, where the crew was planning to destroy the Borg Collective through a very similar method. But the way the two stories are so diametrically opposed is what makes it interesting. In Trek, morality won out and they order was never given, but here the people in charge almost seem to eager to wipe out a race. It’s an excellent take on a familiar story.

A good episode, but not quite as good as its predecessor.

Return to top

Grade: 8/10

Screen Caps

Return to top

Cast:

Edward James Olmos as Commander William "Husker" Adama
Mary McDonnell
as President Laura Roslin
Katee Sackhoff
as Lt. Kara 'Starbuck' Thrace
Jamie Bamber
as Captain Lee 'Apollo' Adama
James Callis
as Doctor/Vice President Gaius Baltar
Tricia Helfer
as Six
Grace Park
as Lt. Sharon 'Boomer' Valerii / Eight

Return to top

Guest Cast:

Aaron Douglas as Chief Petty Officer Galen Tyrol
Tahmoh Penikett as Lt. Karl 'Helo' Agathon
Alessandro Juliani
as Lt. Gaeta
Kandyse McClure
as Dualla
Lucy Lawless
as D'Anna Biers
Rick Worthy
as Simon
Callum Keith Rennie
as Leoben Conoy
Donnelly Rhodes
as Doc Cottle
Matthew Bennett
as Aaron Doral
Bodie Olmos
as Hotdog
Leah Cairns as Racetrack
Eileen Pedde as Mathias
Tiffany Lyndall-Knight as Hybrid

Return to top

 

Creative Staff:

Written By: Michael Angeli
Director: Bill Eagles

Return to top

 

The news script update utility used by Lowerdecks staff Copyright 2003 Andrew Bailey. NOT authorized for use outside the Lowerdecks.com or Trek-UK.com domains without prior consent. Contact Andrew at tcn@lowerdecks.com for more information.

Site Requirements: Optimal viewing with use of Internet Explorer 5.5+ with 1024x768 screen resolution.

Star Trek ® is copyright of Paramount Pictures. Copyright © 1966, Present. The Star Trek web pages on this site are for educational and entertainment purposes only. All other copyrights property of their respective holders.

®2002-Present Lowerdecks.com