Forum | Register | Ranks | BBS Skins | Forum Support | Forum Archive

 

 

series

 

 Other Content
 Smallville
 Lost
 Heroes
 Star Trek: VOY
 Star Trek
 Star Trek: TNG
 Star Trek: DS9
 Mission Logs

 Site Info
 
Staff
 News Archives

 Site FAQ
 Contact
 Terms of Use
 Legal Notice

 Submit News

 Forums
 Main
 Register
 Ranks
 BBS Skins
 Forum Support

The Expanse
Mission Date: April 24, 2153
Original Airdate: May 21, 2003
Reviewed By Kevin Knight

Summary | Review | Screen Caps | Cast | Guest Cast | Creative Staff

Summary

We open with a shot of Earth and a mysterious probe seems to decloak and enter a low orbit. Almost immediately it opens fire upon Florida, North America, carving a line straight through Cuba, and onward to Venezuela. After it quits firing, the probe breaks apart into several pieces and heads for the planet.

Next, the Klingons are discussing the recent history regarding Archer and Duras. The Klingon High Council informs Duras that Archer has escaped him twice, and have made Duras look like a fool. The Council offers Duras one last chance to regain his command and honor. Duras vows he will not fail. Onboard Enterprise, the senior staff are gathered in Archer's ready room. No one knows what's going on, and Hoshi states that Archer has spoken to Admiral Forrest three times in the past hour. Phlox is also surprised he's been summoned to a meeting with the Starfleet officers, since this has not happened before. As the officers are speculating, Archer slowly enters and delivers devastating news - Earth has been attacked. He adds that it's a probe of unknown origin, and it cut a swath 4,000 kilometers long stretching from Florida to Venezuela. Archer then says that it's estimated that at least a million people have been killed. Reed is shocked by this news, as are the rest of the senior staff. Archer then says Enterprise has been recalled. Suddenly, the bridge calls to inform Archer that Admiral Forrest is calling again. Next, Archer orders Travis to set course back to Earth at warp five.

Later, Archer is alone when Trip comes to see him. Trip asks Archer if Forrest told him which part of Florida was hit. Archer says that he didn't tell him, and Trip hopes his sister was away when the attack happened. Archer then informs Trip that the casualty numbers have been updated to three million. T'Pol enters next to report that the Vulcan High Command has recovered the probe and sent it to Starfleet Command. She also says that there was a pilot onboard, but the pilot was killed upon impact. Trip asks her if she knew which part of Florida had been it, but she does not know. Malcolm then calls to report eight Suliban ships are approaching. Archer orders the ship go to tactical alert and the three head to the bridge.

On the bridge, Enterprise attempts to hail them, but they do not respond. The power browns out for a minute, then Suliban soldiers are seen crawling on the bridge ceiling. The power blacks out again, and when it comes back online Archer and the Suliban are gone. On the Suliban ship, Silik confronts Archer.. Archer believes Silik and the Suliban are responsible, but Silik does not know what Archer is talking about. Silik informs Archer that someone wants to see him and they have information that is useful. Silik also adds that the human species is in great danger. Archer is taken into another room, and we see Future Guy. Future Guy tells Archer that a race named the Xindi are responsible for attacking Earth, because the Xindi's homeworld is destroyed 400 years in the future by humans. Archer asks how they found this out, in which Future Guy says people from the future informed them. Archer then asks if it's the person the Suliban are working for, in which Future Guy says the Suliban work for him. Now Archer knows who is responsible for almost starting the Klingon Civil War, and the one who's manipulated his mission from day one. Future Guy says the people who gave the Xindi are another faction, and that the probe was just a test - the Xindi are building a more powerful weapon that will destroy the Earth. Archer asks Future Guy why he's telling him this, and Future Guy says the Xindi are not supposed to know of their future and these events will contaminate the timeline. Archer asks Future Guy why he should believe him, to which Future Guy says Archer has no choice.

April 24, 2153 - Archer's starlog states that the trip home has been difficult, and now over seven million people were lost in the attack. Travis shows everyone the Sol System's star, which brings a moment of silence from the crew. Suddenly, a vessel drops out of warp and fires upon Enterprise. It is discovered this is a Klingon bird of prey, and Duras is in command. Enterprise's forward phase cannons are taken offline, then the Klingons hail Enterprise. The Klingons say that Enterprise will be destroyed unless Archer surrenders. They also say Archer is an enemy of the Empire, and must be brought to justice if honor is to be regained. Duras then disables both of Enterprise's warp nacelles, and begins to prepare a boarding party. Suddenly, three Starfleet vessels enter the scene and damage Duras' ship to the point where he has to retreat. Captain Ramirez of the Intrepid hails Enterprise. He asks who was attacking Enterprise, and wishes Enterprise's homecoming was under better circumstances.

When Enterprise arrives at Earth, they take a low orbit over the attack site. The bridge crew are stunned as they look down at Florida and the impact of the damage. Later, in a briefing with Admiral Forrest and Ambassador Soval, Archer talks about Future Guy and the information he told Archer. Both Forrest and Soval are skeptical, but neither can come up with another explanation. Soval still insists the Vulcan science directorate has deemed time travel impossible. Archer asks both of them if he can take Enterprise and search for the Xindi. Soval asks Archer if he knows where the coordinates Future Guy provided are, and Archer says it's about three months away at warp five. Soval says the area is the Delphic Expanse; a region of space 2,000 light years across. Many Vulcan ships have been there, and only few have returned. Soval goes on to say the area consists of fierce and dangerous species, unexplained events and in some areas the laws of physics do not reply. Soval then talks about a Klingon vessel that entered the expanse and how the crew's bodies were anatomically inverted, and were still alive. Soval is still against the idea, and Forrest says that in order for Enterprise to go Starfleet would need proof.

Archer, Forrest and Soval examine the wreckage of the probe. Archer takes a scanner and begins to quantum date the debris. The first piece appears to be four years old, the next five, the next twelve. Soval and Forrest start to become impatient until Archer finds something interesting. The scanner scans an object and shows the quantum date is -420. That is odd because quantum dating always shows results with positive numbers. A second scanner shows the same reading. Archer then takes a look at the pilot's body. Soval asks Archer if he believes the pilot is a Xindi, and Archer responds by saying he'd like to find out.

In spacedock, Enterprise is undergoing repairs, upgrades and crew replacements. Archer goes to sickbay and meets a Doctor Fer'at who will examine Archer for radiation poisoning. Fer'at begins to examine Archer and asks him a lot of questions about Archer's experience with Future Guy. After a series of questions, Phlox abruptly stops the examination when he discovers Fer'at is actually a analyst sent to see if Archer is losing his mind. This angers Phlox, and Archer asks Phlox to escort Fer'at to the airlock On Earth, Malcolm and Reed are at the site where Trip's sister lived. The area has been totally devastated and Trip points out to Malcolm where the old movie theater was, and where the house was. Reed wonders if Trips's sister is really dead, but Trip says if she was alive someone would have heard something by now.

After a few days of debate, Starfleet finally grants Enterprise permission to proceed with their new mission - to seek out the Xindi. Meanwhile, Archer and Forrest are in a shuttlepod and they take a look at the NX-02, currently under construction. Forrest says she'll be ready to launch in fourteen months. Forrest says that the NX-02 will have the same compliment of weapons as Enterprise, and he asks Archer if he's informed the crew. Archer says he informed them this morning, and that most will go on the mission but some have not made up their mind. Archer then says he spoke with General Casey, and that his team will be coming onboard at 1800 hours. Forrest admits he was surprised Archer asked for them because they are non Starfleet personnel. Archer says he doesn't have any problem with non Starfleet personnel, and that he'll need all the muscle he can get when he enters the Expanse. Later, T'Pol enters sickbay to talk to Phlox about his decision to stay on Enterprise. She tells Phlox that the High Command does not want her to go to the Delphic Expanse. Phlox asks her what she wants to do, but she says that she cannot go against the High Command. Phlox dismisses this and states that she's went against them in the past, and points out the interesting situation she's in - torn between her loyalty between the High Command and Archer. In the armory, Reed and Trip are taking a look at the new photonic torpedoes. They have a longer range and a variable yield that can knock the comm array of a shuttlepod without scratching the hull or could put a three kilometer crater on an asteroid. The two then proceed to reconfigure the power grid for the new torpedoes. On the way, Reed asks Trip if there was going to be a memorial for Trip's sister, but he says she's no more important than the other seven million who were killed. Malcolm says that she was more important to Trip, but he gets angry and tells Reed to let the subject go. Trip then adds that maybe Malcolm should spend more time worrying about upgrading the weapons so he can blow the hell out of the bastards when they find them.

Back at Starfleet, Soval shows Archer and Forrest a transmission from a Vulcan ship that entered the expanse. The crew are acting insanely and are killing each other. Soval suggests to Archer that he needs to reconsider this mission, but Archer's mind is not changed. As they leave, Soval takes T'Pol aside to talk to her. As Soval and T'Pol leave Starfleet headquarters, Soval talks about T'Pol returning home. She asks him why can't get she go with Enterprise on this mission. He says that in the expanse logic will not help Enterprise, but T'Pol says it should be her choice. In spacedock, the last of the refits are completed and Enterprise leaves spacedock on course for Vulcan, to talk T'Pol there. After Enterprise leaves orbit, Duras' ship finds them and starts to follow them.

Later, Duras attacks, but is met with the new torpedoes. He tries to disable Enterprise's weapon ports, but it not successful. Enterprise manages to disable Duras' ship long enough to get to Vulcan space. T'Pol then comes to Archer and talks to him about he allowing her to stay onboard for this mission. She states that she has decided to resign from the High Command, and that Archer is taking Enterprise into a dangerous region, and he needs her. Archer decides to allow her to stay, and orders course adjusted to the Delphic Expanse.

Eventually, Enterprise reaches the outer area of the expanse. Trip dispatches a communication buoy and establishes a channel with Starfleet Command. Suddenly, T'Pol's sensors show that Duras has returned - only this time he has help as three Klingon birds of prey approach. Duras hails Archer and orders him to surrender or be destroyed. Archer replies by yelling "Go to hell!" and cuts off the transmission. The other two birds of prey become afraid of the expanse and turn back. Duras continues ahead, and continues to fire. Archer notices the torpedoes are not having the same effect this time, in which Malcolm reports that Duras has transferred all his shields to forward. This gives Archer some room to maneuver. He asks Travis if he can perform an L-4. When a thick cloud approaches, Travis turns the ship hard and flies over Duras. Duras, blinded by the cloud, does not see this. Enterprise emerges behind Duras and fires three torpedoes, destroying Duras' ship.

All is clear, and Archer orders Travis to continue ahead, straight and steady...

Return to top

Review

If you only watch one season two episode of Enterprise, "The Expanse" should be it. I liked this one because it offers something only a rare few Enterprise (and I dare say, Trek in general) episodes have - suspense, drama, action and a tad bit of character growth - all wrapped up in a little present. From the beginning to the end, I was glued to the television set and was disappointed when the hour was up. "The Expanse" is different from other episodes because it left me wanting more; a feeling The Powers That Be are hoping a majority of viewers have so Enterprise's sagging ratings can rebound next season. Everything about this one just seemed to fit together from the Xindi attack, the Suliban and Future Guy, Duras' hunt for Archer, and Trip's loss.

When I first heard about this one, I will admit I was a bit concerned about this attack on Earth by an unknown alien race and the fact it's never talked about in the future. I thought that things may have been better if the Romulans had attacked and we'd see the start of the Earth-Romulan War. After seeing this one, I think I can handle this sequence of events and believe that "the first time" this never happened and with the tampering with the timeline these events can now be discussed in the 23rd/24th century world. I just hope we see that world again...

The briefing room scene with all the senior staff and Phlox was done extremely well. I liked seeing everyone speculate about what this meeting was about then seeing everyone's reaction to the news that Earth had been attacked and at least a million people had been killed. We see the crew transform from the TNG-like naive feeling to a more DS9-like realistic feeling when they realize that space is a dangerous place, and Earth is not exempt from alien attack. I would like to see more scenes like this during the rest of the series because it gets the entire senior staff involved in what's going on, not just Archer, Trip and T'Pol.

The scenes with Malcolm and Trip were done well. Since "Shuttlepod One," it appears these two are becoming best friends. I do find it amusing how Malcolm is always "doom & gloom" like in "Shuttlepod One" and in "The Expanse" when he's talking about a memorial service for Trip's sister. Also you can almost see a feeling of joy come across Reed when the new photonic torpedoes are being installed.

The attack scenes with Duras added an interesting touch to "The Expanse." We are finally beginning to see the Klingons act like TOS era Klingons, but I was surprised when Duras ordered a withdrawal two times. I would think if he's fighting to regain his honor he would fight to the death, but considering how the Duras Family act in the 24th century, I can see where this would work. A couple times, especially during the Delphic Expanse fight scene, I kept waiting for Duras' First Officer to assassinate him. I also got a tad bit of "The Wrath of Khan" and "Insurrection" feeling while watching the Delphic Expanse attack. You can see Duras wasn't going to give up easily this time, and the Expanse's clouds were almost too much for Enterprise's impulse manifolds. The maneuver Travis made to get around Duras' ship and the firing of the torpedoes was absolutely wonderful, and I actually found myself cheering when the bird of prey was destroyed. One lingering question remains - is Duras dead? His ship wasn't completely destroyed since it blew up in a series of fragments, so it's possible he survived. I guess time will tell.

I also like how everything didn't happen at once. After the attack, it was weeks and months before the Enterprise was ready and sent to the Delphic Expanse. Reed's comment about the day of remembrance for the dead of the attack was a nice touch, and that even at warp five it would take three months to reach the Expanse.

The Good:

Plot - Everything just seemed to fit together. We didn't see any lost chances or dangling plot lines. I actually had to recheck the opening credits to make sure this was actually written by Rick Berman and Brannon Braga

Action, suspense & drama - This one has it. The Duras attack scenes gives us plenty of action and suspense and Trip's loss gives a touch of drama.

Starfleet vessels - The Intrepid and the other two defense ships looked cool. From the viewscreen image, it appears as the bridges of Starfleet vessels pretty much look like Enterprise's.

NX-02 - I loved seeing the NX-02 under construction. I was a bit surprised that it was still going to take fourteen months to complete her, so that should happen around the time of the season four premiere.

Vulcan footage - The Vulcan footage Soval showed Archer and Forrest looked really cool. It reminded me a little of "The Tholian Web" and "The Naked Time/The Naked Now." I wonder if this area is where that virus comes from?

Archer - Forrest - The last scene with the two on Enterprise, just before Enterprise leaves spacedock is very touching and shows how the two seem to be friends. During this scene I kept thinking about A.G. Robinson ("First Flight), and what he would think and say if he were there.

The Bad:

As much as I liked "The Expanse," there are some minor things that could have been better.

Archer - It took the third attack before he decided to use lethal force to defend the Enterprise. The first attack I can understand, but after Enterprise left Earth Archer should have used the new torpedoes set to full power the first time to take out Duras. He has no idea how strong the Xindi will be, so he'll need all those torpedoes and I doubt he'll be able to get any more anytime soon.

T'Pol - Ok, she's supposedly resigned from the Vulcan High Command so she can go with the Enterprise to the Delphi Expanse. If that's so, will everyone still call her Sub-Commander T'Pol, or just T'Pol?

Earth attack - The area of the planet devastated by the probe doesn't look like it would have killed seven million people. The scene where Trip and Malcolm are standing in the town where Trip's sister lived shows the path of destruction. It looks as if the path was only a couple hundred yards across, so I don't see how it could have killed seven million. Maybe 700,000-1.5 million.

Overall, you can't miss "The Expanse." This one has been the highlight of the season, and possibly the series. I definitely recommend watching this one again and again.

Return to top

Grade: 9.5/10 A

Screen Caps (Click to enlarge)

 

Return to top

Cast:
Scott Bakula as Jonathan Archer
John Billingsley
as Dr. Phlox
Jolene Blalock
as T'Pol
Dominic Keating
as Malcolm Reed
Anthony Montgomery
as Travis Mayweather
Linda Park
as Hoshi Sato
Connor Trinneer
as Charles "Trip" Tucker III

Return to top

Guest Cast:
Vaughn Armstrong as Admiral Forrest
Gary Bullock
as Klingon Council Member
David Figlioli
as Klingon Crewman
Gary Graham
as Soval
Daniel Riordan
as Duras
John Fleck
as Silik
L. Sidney
as Klingon Crewman #2
Bruce Wright
as Dr. Fer'at
Dan Desmond
as Klingon Chancellor
James Horan
as Humanoid Figure
Josh Cruze
as Captain Ramirez

Return to top

Creative Staff:
Director: Allan Kroeker
Written By: Rick Berman & Brannon Braga

Return to top

 

The news script update utility used by Lowerdecks staff Copyright 2003 Andrew Bailey. NOT authorized for use outside the Lowerdecks.com or Trek-UK.com domains without prior consent. Contact Andrew at tcn@lowerdecks.com for more information.

Site Requirements: Optimal viewing with use of Internet Explorer 5.5+ with 1024x768 screen resolution.

Star Trek ® is copyright of Paramount Pictures. Copyright © 1966, Present. The Star Trek web pages on this site are for educational and entertainment purposes only. All other copyrights property of their respective holders.

®2002-Present Lowerdecks.com