Forum | Register | Ranks | BBS Skins | Forum Support | Forum Archive

 

 

series

 

 Other Content
 Smallville
 Lost
 Heroes
 Star Trek: VOY
 Star Trek
 Star Trek: TNG
 Star Trek: DS9
 Mission Logs

 Site Info
 
Staff
 News Archives

 Site FAQ
 Contact
 Terms of Use
 Legal Notice

 Submit News

 Forums
 Main
 Register
 Ranks
 BBS Skins
 Forum Support

Judgment
Mission Date: Unknown
Original Airdate: April 9, 2003
Reviewed By T'Bonz

Summary | Review | Screen Caps | Cast | Guest Cast | Creative Staff

Summary

Captain Archer is being held for trial on the Klingon home world. He is considered an enemy of the state for having attacked a Klingon ship and for aiding rebels of the Klingon Empire. He is brought into the courtroom to stand trial. His advocate is Kolos, who will speak for him as the accused are not to speak.

Duras son of Toral testifies against him. Duras was formerly a captain, but was reduced in rank and is now a second weapons officer. He was not able to recapture the rebels he was chasing and that Archer had taken aboard the Enterprise. Duras gives a very different version of the events than Archer's recollection. Archer tries to defend himself and is hit with a pain stick for his troubles.

Later, in his cell, after trying and spitting out targ meat, Archer receives a visit from Kolos, who wants Archer to divulge the location of the rebels. He feels that if Archer does this, the prosecutor will make a deal. Archer refuses, not liking what he's seen of the Klingon justice system thus far.

The trial resumes. Kolos asks for permission to have Archer speak. Archer gives his version of the events. The rebels were part of a colony forcibly annexed by the Klingons, but seemingly neglected by them and left to starve. They left in a ship to go elsewhere, the ship was damaged and Archer and Enterprise aided them, intending to help them relocate, not knowing that the Klingons were after them. There was a skirmish with Duras' ship.

Kolos points out how Archer has been helpful to the empire, and says that while he has meddled in Klingon affairs, he meant no harm. Archer and Kolos then wait for the verdict and Archer has his first taste of bloodwine. Kolos bemoans the changing Klingon society and the loss of honor.

To his dismay, he is found guilty. The death sentence is commuted to labor on Rura Penthe, which is basically a death sentence. Kolos strongly protests this and is insulting enough to the magistrate that HE is sent to Rura Penthe for a year's labor.

Archer gets into his normal fight-of-the-week with a Klingon guard who was cruel to Kolos. New arrivals enter the prison, and one of them is Reed. He says that T'Pol has bribed a corrections officer to get him in there and they have an escape plan. Kolos refuses to go, he can't restore Klingon honor as a fugitive, and he plans to finish out his sentence.

Return to top

Review

The Good:

I rather liked Star Trek VI and this is a steal of it. The view of the Klingon planet. The little touches, such as Archer trying targ meat and bloodwine. Former Captain Duras. Truly the Klingon Duras family is the Tannen (Back to the Future) family of Star Trek. I was waiting for a load of crap to fall on Duras' head in the courtroom.

The Very Good:

Hertzler as Kolos. He was an excellent character and he made the show with such dialogue as the following:
-Kolos: Are all humans like this?
-Archer: Fair?
-Kolos: STUPID!

Funny stuff!

The Bad:

Stolen directly from STVI. Deduction for lack of originality. Archer. Man can this guy be any more obnoxious/arrogant? He really looks like the typical "ugly American" (in this case "ugly Terran/Human".)
The rebel escape. How did they get a ship? It would have been nice to know this.

The Very Bad:

The prison set. Uh….run out of money guys? The rushed ending. It rather seemed like they ran out of time.

The Verdict:

Surprisingly engaging episode, in spite of being lifted from Star Trek VI. (Of course, I like that movie anyhow, so that makes me a bit biased.) Hertzler was superb as always and the little touches of continuity (Duras, targ meat, blood wine) were nice. It would have been nice had they explained just how Archer had fallen into their clutches, but it wasn't a fatal flaw. Having seen Star Trek VI and Kirk et al with the handheld translators, one wonders why Archer didn't seem to need something like that. The ending was poor, it strained credibility to believe that T'Pol could bribe someone and waltz Archer right out of there.

But is spite of the flaws, the show was engaging. The only real complaint that I could lodge is that again we're not seeing fresh stuff, there is too much recycling (although at least this time, the recycling is from Kirk's time, not Janeway's.)

Return to top

Grade: 8.5/10 B+

Screen Caps

Return to top

Cast:
Scott Bakula as Jonathan Archer
John Billingsley
as Dr. Phlox
Jolene Blalock
as T'Pol
Dominic Keating
as Malcolm Reed
Anthony Montgomery
as Travis Mayweather
Linda Park
as Hoshi Sato
Connor Trinneer
as Charles "Trip" Tucker III

Return to top

Guest Cast:
J.G. Hertzler as Kolos
Daniel Riordan
as Duras
Victor Talmadge
as Asahf
John Vickery
as Orak
Helen Cates
as Klingon First Officer
D.J. Lockhart
as Cell Guard
Granville Van Dusen
as Magistrate
Danny Kolker
as Guard

Return to top

Creative Staff:
Director: James L. Conway
Teleplay By: David A. Goodman
Story By: Taylor Elmore & David A. Goodman

Return to top

 

The news script update utility used by Lowerdecks staff Copyright 2003 Andrew Bailey. NOT authorized for use outside the Lowerdecks.com or Trek-UK.com domains without prior consent. Contact Andrew at tcn@lowerdecks.com for more information.

Site Requirements: Optimal viewing with use of Internet Explorer 5.5+ with 1024x768 screen resolution.

Star Trek ® is copyright of Paramount Pictures. Copyright © 1966, Present. The Star Trek web pages on this site are for educational and entertainment purposes only. All other copyrights property of their respective holders.

®2002-Present Lowerdecks.com