Forum | Register | Ranks | BBS Skins | Forum Support | Forum Archive

 

 

series

 

 Other Content
 Smallville
 Lost
 Heroes
 Star Trek: VOY
 Star Trek
 Star Trek: TNG
 Star Trek: DS9
 Mission Logs

 Site Info
 
Staff
 News Archives

 Site FAQ
 Contact
 Terms of Use
 Legal Notice

 Submit News

 Forums
 Main
 Register
 Ranks
 BBS Skins
 Forum Support

The Brig
Original Airdate: May 2, 2007
Reviewed by Diesel Micky Dolenz

Summary | Review | Quotes | Screen Caps | Cast | Guest Cast | Creative Staff

Summary

Locke sits in front of a fire and looks over the contents of a red folder. We hear someone nearby struggling, and Locke tells the someone to save his breath because no one can her him. Locke then tosses the folder into the fire.

8 Days Ago - We pick up at the end of "The Man from Tallahassee." Locke finds his father being held by the Others. Ben insists that it was Locke, and not them that brought dear old Dad to the island. Ben advises Locke to keep his distance, but Locke un-gags his father. Dad promptly bites Locke and gets shocked by Tom. Dad starts ranting, "don't you know, John? Don't you know where we are?" Locke is quickly led from the room. Ben refuses to address Dad's comment, instead telling Locke that the Others are all leaving. He invites Locke to come with them. Locke accepts.

Now - Kate dresses and excuses herself from Sawyer's tent to go sleep in her own. She tells Sawyer she can't sleep unless she's in her own tent. She also doesn't want Sawyer to come with her to sleep in hers. Kate leaves, and Sawyer ventures out to relieve himself. He finds Hurley and Jin standing nervously outside another tent, but doesn't pay them much attention. He runs into Locke, who tells Sawyer that he hasn't joined the Others, he's infiltrated them. He kidnapped Ben and dragged him into the jungle. Why come all the way back to the beach to tell Sawyer that? Locke wants Sawyer to kill Ben for him.

Sawyer tells Locke to kill Ben himself. Locke says he's not a killer. Sawyer insists he isn't either. Locke brings up the man Sawyer killed in Sydney, and says that the Others have background files on all of them. Sawyer says their files have their facts wrong. Locke apologizes for coming to Sawyer, and asks that Sawyer not mention to anyone that he was there. Locke walks off into the jungle, and Sawyer reluctantly follows him.

3 Days Ago - The Others have made a camp. Locke helps Cindy with her tent. The Others all seem to be treating Locke with a sense of reverence and awe. Cindy tells him that they've been waiting for him. Before he can ask why, Tom tells Locke that Ben wants to see him. Locke finds Ben listening to Juliet's taped report on Sun. Ben tells Locke that Juliet is finding out who's pregnant, and in a few days they're going to "take them." Locke doesn't seem to like the sound of that, and Ben assures him that no one will get hurt.

Ben uses a cane and gets out of his wheelchair. He thinks Locke is responsible for his recovery, noting that before Locke he couldn't even feel his toes, but the moment Locke showed up, he started feeling pins and needles. He tells Locke that this is only the beginning, and he can't wait to show Locke what else the island can do. Unfortunately, Ben doesn't think Locke is ready to learn. He says that Locke is still being held hostage by his father. In order to become one of them, he has to put his father behind him. The only way Locke can prove he's done that is by killing him.

Now - Charlie gathers food together in the kitchen. Jack asks about the camping trip, and Charlie just pushes it off as male bonding. Charlie brings the food to the tent that Hurley and Jin were standing outside the night before. They're both there as is Desmond. Jin takes the food inside the tent. Charlie tells Desmond that they need to tell Jack what's going on. Hurley agrees, wanting Jack to check out Naomi's wound. After Jack spent so much time with the Others, Desmond doesn't trust Jack. He asks Charlie and Hurley if they trust Jack enough to jeopardize their possible rescue. Neither of them does, so they need to find someone else that they can trust.

Sawyer and Locke trek through the jungle. Sawyer asks what else is in his file. Locke tells him that it says his father shot his mother then turned the gun on himself when Sawyer was very young. It doesn't, however, say why. Locke goes on that the file has school transcripts and Sawyer's criminal record.

Sawyer knocks Locke to the ground and holds a knife to his throat. He's been conned by Ben before and wants to know why he should believe that this isn't another one of Ben's traps. Locke insists that he's telling the truth. He's leading Sawyer to kill Ben. Sawyer demands to know why Locke doesn't kill Ben himself and Locke is forced to admit that he can't do it. Sawyer lets Locke get up and says that they'll bring Ben back to camp. Sawyer isn't willing to kill anybody. Locke agrees, but tells Sawyer that once he's heard what Ben has to say, he'll change his mind.

Sayid is the chosen trusted one. He's been told about Naomi, but not what she has told them. He's pleased that no one has told Jack what's going on. Naomi tells Sayid that her helicopter crashed in the water. She took off from a freighter about 80 nautical miles west of the island. She's part of a search and recovery team.

Sayid asks about her statement that the wreckage of their flight had been found. She tells them that the entire plane was found off the coast of Bali in an ocean trench four miles deep. It was searched by robotic subs and the bodies were found. She wasn't looking for Flight 815 survivors, she and her team were hired by Penny Widmore to find Desmond. The coordinates they were given were in the middle of the ocean. They thought they were wasting their time until Naomi crashed. She was heading for the ship when the clouds parted and she saw the island. Then her instruments went crazy and the chopper started to go down so she bailed out.

Sayid asks whether anyone saw her helicopter. Nope. Naomi picks up on the idea that Sayid thinks she's lying. He expects that she'll conveniently not have a way to contact the ship, but she's got him there. She shows him the satellite phone.

Locke and Sawyer take a break from their hike. Sawyer tells Locke that he made a mistake in Sydney. He thought the man he killed was someone else, though he won't tell Locke who he thought the man was.

3 Days Ago - Ben wakes Locke and tells him, "it's time." He leads Locke to where Dad is tied to an ancient column and hands Locke a knife. Dad is un-gagged and laughs at the idea that Ben wants Locke to kill him. Locke hesitates. Ben tells him it's because a part of him still wants to believe that there's a good explanation for why Dad stole his kidney and pushed him out an 8th-story window. Dad thinks the hesitation is because Locke is spineless. A crowd of Others starts to gather around.

Locke asks why Ben is doing this to him. Ben says he's doing it to himself. Until he kills his father, he'll still be the guy in a wheelchair that got kicked off a walkabout tour because he couldn't walk. Locke holds the knife to Dad's throat, but can't bring himself to kill. Ben takes the knife from Locke and tells the crowd, "I'm sorry. He's not who we thought he was."

Now - Locke and Sawyer finally reach their destination, the Black Rock. Locke tells Sawyer that Ben is in the ship's brig. Locke opens the brig and we see a man wearing a hood shackled to a bench. Sawyer repeats to Locke that he isn't going to kill anyone, and to make his point he leaves his knife outside the brig. Once inside, Locke closes and locks the door behind him, trapping him inside with "Ben." Sawyer beats on the door, but can't open it. He rips the hood off of the man only to find it'd Dad and not Ben. Sawyer asks, "who the hell are you?"

On the beach, Sayid manages to get the radio/phone powered up, but it can't lock on to a channel to communicate with anyone. All they receive is interference, which Sayid says is blocking their ability to send their own transmission. While Sayid and Hurley discuss the radio, Kate walks up and sees what they're doing. Sayid tells her that if he explains where they got the radio, he wants her to keep it very quiet.

In the brig, Locke sits and waits for Sawyer to kill Dad. Rousseau shows up, grabs a crate of dynamite and leaves.

2 Days Ago - Locke sits on a hillside overlooking the Others' camp. Richard introduces himself and sits beside Locke. He explains that Ben asked Locke to kill Dad in order to embarrass Locke, knowing that Locke wouldn't kill his own father. Why? When people found out that Locke got on the plane with a broken spine but is now walking on the island, they got excited because that could only happen to "someone extremely special." Ben doesn't want anyone to think that Locke is special.

Why is Richard cluing Locke in on this? Richard thinks that Ben has been wasting their time on things like fertility problems. He's looking for someone to remind people that they're there for more important reasons. Richard wants Locke to find his purpose, but for that to happen, Dad still has to die. Richard knows that Locke won't do it, but he brings him a file on someone who will, Sawyer. Why would Sawyer kill Locke's father when Sawyer doesn't even know Locke's father? That's part of the file.

In the brig, Sawyer ends up un-gagging Dad, who condescendingly tells Sawyer that Locke is his son. Sawyer asks how Dad got to the island. Dad finds the idea that they're on an island funny, but he explains how he got there. He was rear-ended while driving on Interstate 10 through Tallahassee. He wrecked at 70 mph. The next thing he knows, he's strapped to a gurney and being loaded into an ambulance. One of the EMT's even smiles at him as he hooks up an IV. The next thing Dad knows, he's tied up and gagged in a dark room, and when the door to the room opens, it's Locke he sees, his dead son whose plane crashed (and was found) in the ocean. Dad figures they're all dead, and all in Hell, not on some island.

Dad tells Sawyer that he threw Locke out of a window which paralyzed him. He did it because Locke was becoming a nuisance. He also mentions that he conned Locke out of a kidney. Sawyer asks Dad's name. Dad's had many names, one of those, Tom Sawyer, really get's Sawyer's attention.

Yesterday - the Others pack up their camp. They're moving. Locke's not invited, nor is his father. Ben promises to leave a trail that Locke can follow if and when Locke kills his father. If Locke does follow them, he better be carrying his father's body on his back.

Now - In the brig, more talk between Sawyer and, well, Tom Sawyer. Sawyer figures out that this is his namesake. This is the man that conned his mother, Mary, taking all his parent savings, prompting his father to shoot his mother before turning the gun on himself. Sawyer pulls out the letter that he carries with him, hands it to Dad, and tells him to read it. Dad starts to read the letter, then stops once he gets past the part about Sawyer's father killing himself. Dad figures out that Sawyer wrote the letter, and that Sawyer took his name as part of his obsession with revenge.

Dad tells Sawyer that he ran that con two dozen times. Sawyer tells him his mother's name was Mary. Dad says he remembers Mary from Jasper, and that she practically begged him to take her $38,000 and take her away from her pathetic little life there. Sawyer tells him to finish reading the letter. Dad says that all he did was take the money, and if Sawyer's father did what he says, that he's probably "down here" somewhere, and Sawyer should "take it up with him."

Sawyer screams at Dad to finish the letter. Dad says he'll finish it, and starts ripping it into pieces. Sawyer snaps. He wraps a chain around Dad's neck and strangles him to death. Locke opens the door and tells Sawyer, "thank you."

Kate finds Jack and Juliet sitting on the beach. She asks to speak to Jack alone. Juliet starts to leave, but Jack tells Kate that anything she has to say to him, she can say to Juliet, too. Kate finally agrees to tell them both, since Juliet is the reason that no one has yet told Jack what's going on. She gives them the run down. Naomi parachuted onto the island, there's a ship, if they can contact it they'll be rescued. Jack asks why no one had told him (duh!), and Kate says that it's because nobody trusts him anymore.

Jack asks how Naomi is supposed to contact her ship. Kate is amazed that Jack isn't phased by the news that none of his friends trust him. He asks again and she tells about the radio/phone. Jack and Juliet exchange a look and Juliet says, "we should tell her." Jack says "no." Kate wonders what they're talking about. Juliet repeats that they should tell Kate. Jack says, "not yet," and walks off.

Sawyer leaves the Black Rock and wretches. He asks Locke why he arranged this. Locke says that Dad ruined both of their lives, and he deserved to die. He then tells Sawyer that Juliet is a mole. He also tells about the plan to grab the pregnant women. Why is Locke telling Sawyer instead of warning the camp himself? He's not going back. He's on his own journey now.

Sawyer doesn't think anyone will believe him, since he's been saying she can't be trusted since she showed up in camp. Locke produces the tape recorder with Juliet's report for Ben. Sawyer asks if it's true that Dad threw Locke out a window and that he was paralyzed. Locke says, "not any more," and walks off.

The final scene is of Locke slinging his father's body over his shoulder and heading into the jungle.

Return to top

Review

Whoever cast Terry O'Quinn as Locke deserves a raise. He played the character perfectly this week, both showing Locke's shrewdness in tricking Sawyer into killing Locke's father and in showing his shame at not being able to kill the old man himself. As much as Locke insisted in "Further Instructions" that he's a hunter, it's still not true. He's not really a farmer, either, though. He still wants to see dear old Dad dead, and he makes it happen. In some ways, it hurts him to have to drag Sawyer into this, but not enough to let it go.

Josh Holloway did a nice job this week, too. As much as Sawyer likes being considered the tough guy, he doesn't like to think of himself as a murderer, and he doesn't like for others to think that, either. I have to wonder whether he could have killed again if "Tom Sawyer" hadn't essentially goaded him into it. It's a miracle that no one killed the smug, grating bastard long before. Even if he did "have it coming," as Locke put it, it still turned Sawyer's stomach. Whether he likes it or not, Sawyer is a murderer, twice over, but he still doesn't have to like it.

So what really was the point of Ben putting Locke up to this? Was it really just to take Locke down a peg in the eyes of the Others, as Richard suggested? Or was it a test to see just how far Locke was willing to go to be accepted into the group and let in on some of the island's secrets? Another question that's raised is whether Richard really is dissatisfied with Ben's leadership or whether that was just another part of Ben's plan.

Speaking of Ben and plans, it'll be interesting to see how things shake out with Jack, Juliet and Ben over the last few episodes. Not that Ben has never made a mistake, but I have to believe that Ben both wanted Locke to know that Juliet was a mole and to know where he kept the tape recorder. He knew that Tom had gone to fetch Locke, so I figure he was listening to the tape for the express purpose of having Locke hear it, too. Was Ben's plan all along to have Locke draft Sawyer, then pass along the tape recorder so that he could out Juliet?

Further complicating the question of Juliet's loyalties is the exchange between her, Jack and Kate. It wasn't exactly a subtle sign that Jack and Juliet have something going on the the rest of the lostaways aren't in on. Do she and Jack think they're pulling one over on Ben? If so, is Ben aware of it, and that's why he's outing her as a mole? What part of the conversation prompted Juliet to suggest to Jack that they tell Kate what's going on? Was it the fact that the other lostaways no longer trust Jack, or is it directly related to the fact that there's possibly a rescue boat sitting 80 miles off shore?

The spot where the Others first built there camp was likely not coincidence, either. Ben referred to it as a new place, but also an old place. The ruins where Anthony Cooper was tied up looked quite old, likely much older than the Black Rock, which Locke placed as being from the mid nineteenth Century. How much does Ben know about the people who built those ruins? It seems likely that they were the same people that built the four-toed statue that Sayid, Sun and Jin saw from Desmond's sailboat at the end of last season.

Finally, we have Anthony Cooper backing up Naomi's story of the Flight 815 plane being found, complete with bodies. Cooper thought it meant he was in Hell, though I wouldn't think that people in Hell can be killed off. It seems to back one fan theory that the island is some sort of purgatory, but we've been told in interviews that it isn't the case, and the fact that it seems to be being pushed onscreen leads me to think that it's a bit of misdirection.

As usual, we get a few answers and more questions. Don't complain, though, that's one of the things that makes the show great. To see how well the creative forces behind the show have threaded these sometimes seemingly unrelated storylines, and have them touch in place that must have been planned years in advance, is one of the joys of watching the show in the first place.

Return to top

Quotes

Sawyer (to Hurley and Jin): What the hell are yall doing?
Hurley: What the hell are you doing?
Sawyer: Going to take a leak.
Hurley: Yeah, well, so are we.
Sawyer: (pause) Well alrighty then.

Sayid: Well, obviously we're not dead.

Naomi: Remind me not to rescue you, Sayid.

Sawyer: I thought he was someone else. I made a mistake. I didn't mean to kill him.
Locke: Well, who'd you mean to kill?

Anthony Cooper: A little hot for heaven, isn't it?

Return to top

Grade: 9/10

Screen Caps (Click for larger image)

   

Return to top

Cast:

Naveen Andrews as Sayid
Henry Ian Cusick
as Desmond
Emilie De Ravin
as Claire
Michael Emerson
as Ben
Matthew Fox
as Jack
Jorge Garcia
as Hurley
Josh Holloway
as Sawyer
Daniel Dae Kim
as Jin
Yunjin Kim
as Sun
Evangeline Lilly
as Kate
Elizabeth Mitchell
as Juliet
Dominic Monaghan
as Charlie
Terry O'Quinn
as Locke

Return to top

Guest Cast:

Nestor Carbonell as Richard
Mira Furlan
as Rousseau
M. C. Gainey
as Tom
Kevin Tighe
as Locke's Dad
Marsha Thomason
as Naomi
Kimberly Joseph
as Cindy

Return to top

Creative Staff:

Written by Damon Lindelof & Carlton Cuse
Directed by Eric Laneuville

Return to top

 

The news script update utility used by Lowerdecks staff Copyright 2003 Andrew Bailey. NOT authorized for use outside the Lowerdecks.com or Trek-UK.com domains without prior consent. Contact Andrew at tcn@lowerdecks.com for more information.

Site Requirements: Optimal viewing with use of Internet Explorer 5.5+ with 1024x768 screen resolution.

Star Trek ® is copyright of Paramount Pictures. Copyright © 1966, Present. The Star Trek web pages on this site are for educational and entertainment purposes only. All other copyrights property of their respective holders.

®2002-Present Lowerdecks.com